Catering Menu

Welcome to our exclusive menu for your special gatherings or just because gatherings.
We can customize for your specific needs.

Please note the many items need advance notice.

Questions? Just give us a call: (716) 648-4750

If you have a food allergy, please notify us.

  • John & Mary’s Deluxe Deli Tray

    Our Version of a Charcuterie Board
    Serves 12-16
    $67.00 pre-order

    A delicious assortment of cold cuts and sliced cheeses:
    Roast Beef, Turkey, Genoa Salami and Ham
    Pepper Jack, Swiss and Provolone Cheese

  • Custom Sub Trays

    $65.00 3 hours notice

    Select 5 of our award winning cold cut subs quarter cut.

    Select bread, white or wheat, protein and cheese. All subs come with fresh lettuce and tomatoes. Condiments included, mayo, mustard and oil. Banana peppers and onion available upon request. Included on the side, dill pickle spears and chips.

  • Popular Combo Tray

    Serves 12-16
    $76.00 3 hours notice

    A delectable combination of 4 large cold cut subs, quarter cut and 4 of our gourmet wraps of your choice. All condiments and chips are included... ready to serve.

  • Cold Cut Wrap Platter

    Serves 12-16
    $56.00 3 hours notice

    Create your own combination of wraps made from the freshest ingredients. Choose any 8 wraps - Ham, turkey, Roast Beef or Tuna with lettuce, tomato and cheese of your choice. White, wheat and jalapeño wraps available. We arrange them on a tray giving you 16 pieces. Chips included on the side.

  • Gourmet Wrap Platter

    Serves 12-16
    $72.00 3 hours notice

    Custom wraps... select any 8 of our specialty wraps. We arrange them on a tray giving you 16 pieces. Chips included on the side.

  • Giant 3 to 8 foot Party Sub!

    Serves 5-6 per foot
    $15 per foot 24 hour notice

    Create your own to suit your party’s needs with a selection of any of our our cold cuts per foot. All come with lettuce, tomato and cheese. Condiment served on the side, including hot peppers and onions.

  • Party Pizza

    32 cut pre-order

    Cheese only
    $34.99
    Add toppings
    $3.59 each

  • Wings & Fingers

    Jumbo Wings
    (50) $58 (100) $110

    Boneless Wings
    (50) $45 (100) $85

    Chicken Fingers
    (25) $65 (50) $125

  • Ultimate Buffalo Food Tower

    Something for Everyone!
    $125 pre-order

    Combination of:
    40 Buffalo Chicken Wings
    50 Boneless Wings
    15 Chicken Fingers
    8 Pizza Logs
    Double order of our fried Vegetables
    Topped with Onion Rings!
    All dips included, just bring your appetite.

  • Party Salads, Serves 10-12

    • Caesar Salad
    • Greek Salad
    • Classic Italian Antipasto
    • Harvest Apple Salad
    • Simple Chef Salad

  • Caesar Salad $40 add chicken $10
    Fresh romain lettuce topped with shaved Parmesan cheese, lightly seasoned croutons and tossed with our a dressing.

    Greek Salad $40 add chicken $10
    Crunchy iceberg lettuce, diced tomatoes, crumbled Feta cheese and sliced black olives tossed with our homemade Greek dressing and topped with peperoncini.

    Classic Italian Antipasto $55
    Fresh iceberg lettuce topped with an assortment of our classic Italian meats, fresh sliced cheese, tomatoes, sliced black and green olives and sliced onions, topped with peperoncini. We suggest our homemade Italian dressing.

    Harvest Apple Salad $45 add chicken $10
    A blend of mixed greens topped with cranraisins, pecans and crumbled goat cheese then sprinkled with crunch apple chips. We suggest our homemade maple vinaigrette dressing, sure to please.

    Simple Chef Salad $35
    A blend of mixed greens topped tossed with fresh tomatoes and shredded carrots, topped with our blended cheese, croutons and sliced onions. Your choice of dressing.

  • Fresh Vegetable Platter

    Small $27.95 serves 8-12
    Medium $39.95 serves 12-20
    Large $49.95 serves 20-30

    A colorful blend of fresh seasonal vegetables arranged on a serving platter with ranch dip.

    24 hour notice

  • Soup

    Made daily, call for selections.

    Quart (32 oz.), includes crackers and spoons. $10.99

  • Ultimate Cookie Tray

    12 jumbo, fresh made Chocolate Chip Cookies.

    $24.59 pre-order

  • Ultimate Cookie Tray

    12 jumbo, fresh made Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookies.

    $24.59 pre-order